Our Menu
Just the Classics
Appetizers
Garlic Bread
$5.00
made with 100% Wisconsin butter
Garlic Bread with Cheese
$7.00
our garlic bread baked with mozzarella cheese ontop
Salads
romaine + iceberg tossed in our famous vinaigrette dressing, topped with tomato, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, pepperoncini, and black olives
Classic Antipasto
$5.00/side
$12.00/small
$24.00/large
Entree
includes 1 order of garlic bread
Classic Lasagna
$15.50
our classic casserole since 1954, made with meat sauce, includes a complimentary garlic bread
Spaghetti
$11.00
classic spaghetti tossed with either marinara or meat sauce and topped with parmesan cheese, served with a slice of our butter dripping garlic bread.
Spaghetti & Meatballs
$14.00
classic spaghetti tossed with either marinara or meat sauce, topped with parmesan cheese and 3 meatballs, served with a slice of our butter dripping garlic bread.
Cavatappi Alfredo
$14.00
house alfredo tossed with cavatappi noodles, add chicken or mushrooms for an upcharge, served with a slice of our butter dripping garlic bread.
Mia's Pizza
Create your own OR choose anyone of our specialty pizzas
14" Build Your Own
$14.00/base
meat/extra cheese - add $2.50 each; veggies - add $2 each; choose from sausage, pepperoni, anchovies, bacon, canadian bacon, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, pineapple, jalapenos, pepperoncinis, black olives, cream cheese, cheddar cheese
14" Classic EBA
$28.00
sausage + pepperoni + fresh mushrooms + onion + green pepper + tomato + black olive + mozzarella
14" Wisconsinite
$22.00
pepperoni + pineapple + jalapeno + cream cheese dollops + mozzarella
14" Veggie
$24.00
fresh mushroom + green pepper + onion + tomato + black olive + mozzarella
14" BBQ Chicken
$23.00
honey BBQ sauce base + mozzarella + chicken + green pepper + jalapeno + red onion
14" Carnivore Pizza
$24.00
sausage + pepperoni + canadian bacon + bacon + mozzarella
14" Margherita
$21.00
garlic olive oil base + mozzarella + diced tomatoes + fresh basil
14" BBQ Bacon
$23.00
bbq sauce base + bacon + pepperoni + onion + mozzarella + cream cheese dollups
Sandwiches
prepared in between our butter dripping garlic bread, served with chips
Cheesy Meatball Sandwich
$14.00
meatballs + mozzarella + red sauce in-between our garlic bread
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$11.00
mozzarella baked in-between our butter garlic bread
Catering
1/2 pans and full pans available for pickup with a 24 hour advanced notice. Please call 262.242.2340 during our operational hours with any questions or would like to place an order. 1/2 pan is 9" x 13" - serves 6 to 10 individuals and includes 6 garlic breads with any pasta. Full pan is 13" x 20" - serves 15 to 20 individuals and includes 10 garlic breads with any pasta.
Antipasto Salad
$35.95/1/2 pan
$49.95/full pan
Greens base topped with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni slices, diced tomatoes, sliced black olives, and pepperonchinis. Served with sides of Mama Mia's house-made oil & vinegar dressing.
Lasagna
$79.95/1/2 pan
$124.95/full pan
Mama Mia's classic recipe since 1954 - layers of noodles, meat sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Add fresh mushrooms +$9.99
Spaghetti
$74.95/1/2 pan
$99.95/full pan
Classic spaghetti tossed with your choice of our house-made marinara or meat sauce, then topped with parmesan cheese and parsley.
Cavatappi Alfredo with Chicken
$89.95/1/2 pan
$139.95/full pan
Cavatappi noodles tossed with Alfredo sauce and grilled chicken, then topped with shredded parmesan and parsley.
Garlic Bread
$5.00/per slice
$44.95/10 pack
Our original recipe baked to order, dunked in 100% Wisconsin butter and sprinkled with garlic salt.
Meatballs
$24.95/10 pack
$45.95/20 pack
A delicious blend of ground beef and seasonings formed into a 2 oz ball.